Nurses told his father died of medical colleagues

yesterday morning, Jin Shuhua come to court, she sued the Haidian District Health Board hospital where the doctors of their punishment. Health Bureau, said last June, the Council submitted to the Millennium Monument handling of the hospital report said the Committee for discussion by the hospital against medical malpractice, identified the primary responsibility for man-made emergency physician Zhang and Zhang transferred from the emergency department decided to stop the promotion of time, less then one-time cost of labor time, eliminates the emergency department director. Zhang also gives the hospital administrative warning, emergency department shall be deducted more than 7,000 yuan, head of the emergency department shall be deducted 3 months post allowance. The bureau said the hospital has indeed been verified on the responsibility and the responsibility of departments to deal with.
Jin Shuhua proposed, in accordance with relevant regulations, the punishment of doctors conducted by the health administrative department, not the health administration department of the hospital Millennium Monument. Department of Health said this, the Ordinance does not require the health administrative department Municipal Health Bureau reported that they had to consult this year on Feb. 10, the council will receive the City Municipal Health Bureau of Medicine reply letter that the subject is usually identified medical malpractice medical institutions, medical personnel did not provide for the responsibility of the relevant be identified. Therefore, the council about the lack of medical personnel basis for punishment.
Jin Shuhua this said,
>> dialogue

My purpose is not punishment doctors, but to Because the Health Department can not be made under penalty of medical identification, they must ask them to re-identification.

Jin Shuhua: first or second instance, I have asked, but did not re-identification. I think the expert conclusion ignores the most important issues of misdiagnosis, looking for medicine will be asked, but no one to answer.
>> lawyers say

One problem: The Bureau of Health
Beijing law firm Pacific Century ZHANG Zhen, director of medical affairs: Regulations Although there is no looking for?
Second problem: The Bureau of Health,
ZHANG Zhen: identification of a clear conclusion that the wrong behavior, can correspond to the corresponding responsibilities of doctors should not quibble.
to the three: the hospital medical staff on an administrative warning, you can replace the Health Department?
ZHANG Zhen: warning hospital belongs to the administrative nature of the internal management, and health administration department, the nature of punishment is two, can not be said to be from within the penalty of the administrative penalty. Current medical staff administrative penalty, there are warning, suspension practice, practice certificate revoked.
>> related to the case

2006 年 5 29, Jin Shuhua 79-year-old father left abdominal pain, the nurses were sent to Jin Shuhua Millennium Monument of any hospital. Zhang emergency room doctor on duty to the elderly injected after diagnosis, Since then, pale old man, was transferred to Department of Cardiology, diagnosed as a 6 June that year, old people died. The following year on June 5, Haidian District, Medical Malpractice Medical Association to the book, that the case constitutes a Class A medical malpractice,abercrombie & fitch milano, the hospital held a slight liability.
patient's family refused to accept this conclusion, commissioned by the Municipal Health Bureau, Beijing Medical Malpractice Medical Association once again made, conclusions unchanged, medicine, negative secondary responsibility. Jin Shuhua other five children, proceedings, claims 19 million yuan, of which mental damages of 5 million. The adoption of the Beijing Haidian Court of First Instance of Medical Malpractice Medical Association, ruling Millennium Monument hospital medical expenses for compensation to the families of the deceased more than 4 million yuan. Family of the deceased lodged an appeal in the Court of Final Appeal upheld the original one.