Explanation:
Explanation:
One person:
the number for the village of Zhao we are not quite sure I have consist in ...ked, local people say they are certainly higher than 100 to more people. Then for the reflection of the local people, we said yesterday in an interview, they said many people are not sure, then do not quite comprehend how the case is going on, or there is to know things, but also do not want to talk too much with us seq. Especially his family, when asked to these things, when asked today, they are, they will say they are afraid to say more.
Explanation:
you to the village how long?
Yong-Sheng Chen (Peking University Law School Professor):
not agonizing, is said to be no complaints when asked why, Zhao Zuohai said before is not good social life imprisonment after emotion
bow, was acquitted loosened, Zhao Zuohai signed the legal documents.
first mistake, let's apology, admit this is the first tread, the tread we all know, has been mistaken. Finally, I think, a very important one is that even after the mistake and correction, error correction. I think the key is to correct mistakes later, to prevent the repetition of similar errors, this is the most important.
Moderator:
Okay, thank Wang Jin.
Reporter:
Moderator:
actually Typically, the facts are clear, the death penalty should be implemented, but the lack of evidence, practice, suspended death sentence, leaving apartment for the verdict, in fact, is a violation of law. Facts are not clear should be not guilty contracting. In agreement with the law, vehicle is now a conviction of criminal proceedings, called the presumption of innocence, sin is never asked is suspected of.
One person:
(Play video)
such a key thing, along to our reform after the expiry of the legal nefarious proceedings, or call the presumption of innocence, or called the Conflict of the conception, this is should not be sentenced, but also sentence, as arrested in front of, and litigation, and the last sentence. When the sentence may be someone a mini morsel of stirring a bit, do not have the death penalty, the last one still left to live on. Or more afraid of is that if a death sentence had the case, how should like Zhao noon back?
Zhaozuo Lan (Zhao Zuohai sister):
Explanation:
Moderator:
just legal specialists say, and from the process point of view, which I can conclude that the navel must have torture, how do you see?
I think this reflects some of his weak areas, he said I have feed well on the appearance, so instead here is a kind of truce It also put up. In fact, some time, and time will make a lot of mistakes attempting to settle down, and even innocent people will start to deem I was not really wrong. This is a very terrible thing, so I think now we are faced with Zhao Zuohai this case, the whole of our public security system to study the course, as we have said,
纪念中国人民抗日战争胜利65周年座谈会在京举行, the first firm does not torture. Second, determined to act the legal presumption of innocence and the Conflict of such a legal principle. Third, the public security organs must not say that I maintain peer's face, you give a peer's face, and let the law lost so much face. Fourth, I think you can not go, I want to regulations, for example, I want to on a regular root, how much I want to break the number of cases, I pursue the special action, I want to set a percent, put relentless.
but I think he can not appeal, but we have our own public security error adjustment, error improvement must be, in fact, the middle ... ...
If entire correlates so we had to turn off,
alife chuck low, but when the file to the prosecution, when there is no opportunity to cut down?
case,
国务院扶贫办：未来十年基本消除绝对贫困, distinct party, admit that he and Zhao Zuohai, Zhao noon the Du Jinmei also has an happening with the media reflect a similar situation.
is his brother.
He buffet me because to say that, let me admit with Zhao Zuohai well, he made me kneel on the mallet to hit me, that is, with my implementation of the implementation of the situation. Asked me to kill you at the time he was not there, what happened, if you present you Diming, I do not know. I said I do not know, he killed he did not kill him, I do not know.
Why do we need this to work together to answer, and when Zhao Zuohai been released back, have some of the details, people feel really looked after intricate.
Explanation:
Wang Jin:
One person:
the torture first, we now have a direct celebration to answer an interview that what is being said that he called a good friend, including his own with his sisters words. Another point,
air jordans shoes, I think we need to do a turn, move card, please come up with the local public security organ of the evidence you do not torture, let solo in the treatment process is now in fact have been narrated to admission of local people may there is torture.
Wang Jin, hello.
before he had to said to you?
I just said to resolutely chase a responsible, this can not be said. Because no matter the time now passed, numerous, numerous years played down the things, the case when no run, even if they are already in the state of advancement, how wrong physical condition, or even not work and so forth, can not be Select a reason not to revive, so we are glad to see that in the first day of the Henan High Court when the press conference, clearly said that the State Compensation start, the Responsibility starts, well, determined to pursue responsible, not because of the time liability to give up the chase.
third I think a very important point is that a 57-year-old, 46 in, 57 out of 11 years colossal changes in China, what will now state compensation to his hands, When not sure now, he still can not go, he lives the afterward few decades will be how to attach to, only the help of the administration I muse is insufficient, need a lot more to civil society organizations to help him and let him lull down extra, and can actually begin to life in the future, any individual should be enough of these to help, not to say the hero is a trumped them.
even then the weak, the necrosis discipline can not be casually ahead to recognize the of the.
Moderator:
Wang Jin:
Wang Jin:
Jin Chunji (Hubei Jingshan County Court):
Moderator:
Moderator:
right. When asked today to give his uncle, when Zhao, and his uncle had been disinclined to say more.
Another point I think we can temporarily leave the law, common sense back to our lives, you will find a no kill this person, because Zhao noon back, it did testify that he really did not kill Zhao noon, Why would he admit it?
Explanation:
Wang Jin:
so it is essential to cultivate the system. There is another detail we memorandum that, in these 11 years, the Zhao Zuohai name is a wrong case, an injustice, not an appeal or complaint before?
Wang Jin (this correspondent):
Zhao Zuohai Henan Provincial High Court found willful murder was a clear wrong. Briefing, there is a detail aroused our care, in the May 10, 1999, to June 18 the same year, during police interrogation, Zhao Zuohai guilty of a total of 9 statements made, that does not kill Zhao Zuohai 9 recognition of the relevant crimes.
inside these days, you look at the village of Zhao, the digit of people about their progress in this matter for now to this point, what kind of reflection of some back inside the village, Zhao Zuohai do you think the next life be favor?
Explanation:
Now, the fate of similar Zhao Zuohai also faces re-start in life, he will also must face to him, has torn apart lives. Look anew, Zhao Zuohai taken the moment the prison doors, we are also worried about the future, what does it really have a future?
Moderator:
right and what the murder must be solved, I think solve the case is also a science of living, we must follow the laws of science.
(Play video)
Explanation:
should be said that Wang Jin gives us a very essential message, a wrong circumstance was postponed for 11 years who came out, there ought be a mighty appetite to talk, but fair the inverse.
subtitles Tip:
Zhao Zuolan:
for investigators at the time if there is any act of torture, it is also looking amenable to the last careful examine of the relevant departments. But even when acts of torture does not exist, the local court's determination on Zhao Zuohai, but also to the people concerned about the center of the case of doubt, kill cut into chips, if the evidence is conclusive, why sentence of death with reprieve it?
you see Zhao Zuohai himself?
that after the case,
air maxes, people feel curious, feel calm and at the same time also said that fortunate ah, thanks to Zhao noon he was competent to come back, If he had did not come back, Zhao Zuohai what happens?
Chen Yongsheng:
Reporter:
even get state compensation, and now he has been very tough to go back to normal life, but fate and Zhao Zuohai deviate from the route, like, there is an experience very similar people. Today, many media outlets are invariably Zhao Zuohai and another man to put together remarks, they are victims because of the resurrection is the final injustice to light, are also already serving 11 years after being acquitted, he is a farmer in Hubei SHE .
1997, the village of villagers Zhao Zhao noon suddenly faded, his family reported to the police. Since then,
中国发布655个城市环境综合整治考核结果, and fellow villagers Zhao Zhao Zuohai midday there had been two fights, the regional police as a surmise Zhao Zuohai additional investigation, more than 20 days in custody, deserving to absence of evidence for his release. After more than a year, the local villagers dig wells, they found a mindless body of a male, suspected that the missing Zhao noon. Zhao Zuohai as a major suspects have been caught along the police orchestra and two years later, he was sentenced to death for intentional assassinate, suspended for two years. Zhao noon for the resurrection, Henan Province Higher People's Court fast reflected. Yesterday, the Henan Province Higher People's Court held a news conference, Zhao Zuohai notice ashore the retrial case situation. Adjudication council, Zhao Zuohai alleged innocent, and start the state compensation procedures, and accountability mechanisms to start there.
hundred percent I think this is torture, because the prevalent sense knows that if recognition of the consequences of murder are very serious, normally the death penalty, even now do not know the death penalty is premeditated murder, the consequences are very serious, no one knows everyone.
I said, Where have the years you were dead, he said I ran a few areas, I say you come back, ah ye I say you this thing has magnificent ah, then I say you die a whole village to know.
why the particular emphasis on the 3 firm?
I saw, about 9 o'clock, we are Zhaozuo Hai's brother met Zhao Zuohai home. Then he was on a repast, when a reporter asked him a question of time, no matter what questions to ask, his answer is, he said he motivated, and then the worst, to say naught, and now all the reporters have been very polite to call out their home, move forward in the door.
Today, we are only a few freeze-frame through the scene over to Zhao Zuohai laud as many as possible to regain emancipation, merged feelings, because reporters have not adjoin This is the party wrongly caged for 11 years. Zhao Zhao Zuohai uncle held that the county public security office received a phone before, Zhao Zuohai should now be brought to travel. After revision in Zhaozuo Hai Zhao family's first apply was not to arrest the perpetrators, not litigation, but state compensation. Zhao Zhao Zuohai held yesterday, the uncle said they will intend the value of compensation not fewer than 50 million, the standard is 127 yuan per day. Statu
tory vacations and other vacations It’s about time to reckon the twice or triple.
One person:
Moderator:
giving the impression of a discount recognition of the label.
and in the second sentence says that only after the truth so that the intricate case, to truth, this sentence still involve solemn legal lack of esteem, and even I think this should hold him amenable, because we have started from 1996, the presumption of innocence and the Conflict. In his words also contain secluded inside the suspicion of Zhao Zuohai, is not that complicated case you did, this is dreadful. So I think we must resolutely mistaken, wrong is wrong, I think for us to do the local public security system and the people who had the case, but also to the national public security system provides a advising of the chance that only authentic mistake in peccadillo , did not make mistakes come. If the face of such errors, not really admit, the last excuses in the past, the future may also make mistakes, more injustice than the injustice is still injustice in the future should a alike casualty.
2010 年 5 月 10 日 CCTV
Yesterday, when informed that 57 people in Henan Zhao Zuohai Zhecheng County after being acquitted of some of his villagers collect in the village, to see through the 11-year jail sentence for Zhao Zuohai what it is. Zhao Zuohai of people want to see, and maybe Zhao noon, he is court-ordered decrees in 2000 referred to by Zhao Zuohai kill people. Has been
I think the important point is that people will talk about the case had SHE Hubei, Murder, DNA also did not get on and so on, but in the end also sentenced, finally there is such a problem. But that time has not changed the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1996 when the revised Code of Criminal Procedure clearly, we might look like two. One is Article XII: Next, we see,
Moderator:
frank Li (Zhao village of village secretary):
Moderator:
this process, you will find a elaborate, that is, in fact, said Zhao seems that a headless corpse thought that Zhao noon, but later also found in other people, and Zhao noon in fact, looking back, before scampering in the Pro also other things, on the gate,
mbt shoes buy, which is really a detail, then fine if we idea that, not later than ten years, back to see the evidence, then, why would not the Code of Criminal Procedure, and the 1996 After the completion of revisions below or speculation of naturalness, or the Conflict, to appliance the spirit of the law so?
not say I went to him, he told me in a not said, do not say anything, do not say, I say that others (Zhao noon) are all back, you said you killed a noisy rumpus, how you kill people back. He started to call, I did not kill, he said. He said he refuses to accept other people beat him, get him to the Public Security Bureau, he said later, he was not the trial could not have asked him, and others hammer him, he said, was the killer.
Du Jinmei:
One person:
confess the 1st fixed is important, for this is just a miscarriage of it? I know thatit is a accumulation of miscarriages of righteousness, injustice for Zhao Zuohai too, for the truth that also ########, and the result is too wrong, so it is a fusion of miscarriages of righteousness. So the position was confirmed after a miscarriage, you should strongly faulted. Why should resolutely it? In the process, just these few days period, we also listened some voices, such as some human mention we do not have any evidence of torture. The second argument is that merely the case that the real corpse without a head after the destroy, so will the truth. These 2 mediocre folk is not to say, are some of the mission compel, or the judicial person outlook.
Wang Jin:
1994 farmers in Hubei SHE charges for killing his wife, was sentenced to 15 years, spent 11 months in prison for the Spring and Autumn, to be released from prison in his time, killed his wife appeared suddenly alive, then and today SHE Zhao Zuohai also like acquitted 11-year injustice was finally righted.
One person (Commentator):
One person:
way, we can go to think of many, many things, for instance, is not that some people do not want to talk too much about him, or being present in process , or how and how. But anyway, in the face of Zhao Zuohai first came out, we need to do several things, first is strongly mistaken, the second is the Responsibility firm, and the third is determined to help soothe and Zhao Zuohai.
Moderator:
back to the village that Zhao Zuohai own it?
One person:
Wang Jin:
This is an assumption that we defiance not do, but there are a number of assumptions we have to do, for instance, he was sentenced to a stay of execution for premeditated murder, but If he really is murder, evidence, along with the chopped graphs, then, should the death penalty. Lawyers mustld a suspected guilt have such a lighter result, we make a hypothesis?
One person:
the mind I want to dead by any time, suicidal thoughts at any time, there is a thought because I did not slay, I think there is all obtain to the base one day.
Explanation:
One person:
sticks.
wife gone, kids gone, and not 1 out.
public and the media these days are extremely cared almost a case, precisely, is a wrong case, because of the sudden resurrection of the victim, the defendant becomes a reprieve from the aboriginal acquittal to such a easy whether the parties have spent 11 years.
Moderator:
Moderator:
limit of observation.
Moderator:
SHE:
Moderator:
One person:
if the lead sentence, the decree may be a capital crime, then Zhao Zuohai mind is how accurate you think?
what time you playing?
me to this village for two days.
Moderator:
was very politely query somebody out?
Moderator:
Explanation:
So I say first of all should thank Zhao noon, because he came back, but not too late in coming back, every decade or so if you wait until then time, estimated Zhao Zuohai has put out. If you did not because if he comes back, Zhao Zuohai inside, is now act well at last he is to death, reprieve for two years, and then after a two sentence may be in prison to be about 18 to 20 years, the concept, at fewest, but also squatting fall butme years, so he came out, sixty years age, 6 or seven years old, and you are not sure, at that time Zhao noon also be able to come back, this is the first, that he will proceed squatted. Second,
where can i buy ghd straighteners, all people would think he was criminal, because at last, is squatting over nearly 20 years out. Third, our public security system will lose a self-correcting, self-alert chance.
Wang Jin:
this speculation to think you can do in fact, the opening of public security system itself is wrong arrest, then that is wrong to bring a lawsuit, and then finally the wrong disk. Because a wave amid the distorted rope to every other, I am fearful the last sentence when the magistrate has also been one, because it has some gist of the evidence does not exist, for example, to do DNA testing, that the headless corpse to do DNA time, or even get in Liaoning do. But the details show that I could do, it's not right on.
Moderator:
you just said is firmly admit, there is solace for Zhao Zuohai own compensation, which details the implementation of which is not effortless to ignore?
Xiao-meng, hello.
so in front of either parties to approve the things stated in an interview, there are now, nevertheless not recognize the starting, but then again there is related to torture, say, or that we do not talk about them, you take it you do not have evidence of torture.
this time gave the apology, SHE really can not completely heal the wound. SHE has been utterly destitute after his release, state compensation nearly 46 million, SHE took the money back to society. He did malt bargains, but also opened a small canteen, but a fashionable life path would not be so smooth, SHE's efforts, and finally ended in failure. Due after one year can not furnish the drastic mart rivalry, he closed the canteen, and has since disappeared from view.
not previously, he can not say.
Zhao Zuohai other does not appeal, do not appeal, is not it also be understood as a number of the believe he lost belief in what?
Moderator:
One person:
anguish that you are going to be released in the news.
Moderator:
the latest news is that Zhao Zuohai has returned to his family - Zhao village of, our reporter Wang Jin is on the scene, and now the articulation her.
today when you ask, you mean yesterday or the day before yesterday, when asked, their intonation is not the same, right?
this should be the sibling with him, but immediately no one to discern how he came back, so not sure.
11 annuals in prison, Zhao Zuohai wives and babies, media reports, when Zhao Zuohai completed the signing of lawful documents behind the acquittal, bowed, yet thanks to whom , did not detail.
Du Jinmei (sound):
you can not know what causes the change they reasoned?
according to them is the alarm of retaliation, but retaliation specifically where this is less clear.
Zhao Zuolan:
Moderator:
tory One person
Threaded Mode