A lost ID card was only the police have detained 35 days, because some documents with his rent and crime, and now he sued the police to seek compensation and apology. Photo
reporter Yang Enze Ah was working in Guangzhou (the parties requested a pseudonym) said the loss of identity card to let him into endless trouble, the police have also been identified as the suspect was detained for 35 days, though ultimately the facts unclear, insufficient evidence released, but the nightmare has not yet been arrested away. A return of the free only because of dissatisfaction with the police for compensation, then the police turn to court. Yesterday afternoon, the Guangzhou Municipal Intermediate People's Court heard the case, will choose a sentencing date.
lost ID card
A is Zhoukou Shenqiu County, seven or eight years ago, came to Guangzhou to work. A few years ago, he worked in the security of Yuexiu District, Mineral Street, and later had some savings, he resigned from the security work. In 2009, he and his brother, after discussions, management intends to buy a car transport business.
2010 年 1 14, planning to return home before the New Year Ah, but accidentally lost the wallet. He said the wallet was 300 yuan in addition to a train ticket from Guangzhou to Luohe, there are several hundred dollars in cash and his ID card. Lost wallet that day,
Man after midnight, chopped 2 workers waiting for the arrival of the police (Figure ), he had Palit local police station, thinking that maybe the police to help him find a lost wallet, but ultimately failed to find the lost wallet.
home for Spring Festival, Ah just re-apply for identity cards at the local police station. In mid-May this year, Afghanistan was back home to get a new ID card wheat harvest, Southern A reporter saw the ID card for the time before February 5 this year.
A was never expected, the loss of identity, then let him become a suspect. A just said that he later learned from the police handling the case mouth, picked up his identity card after by others for rent.
cafe was arrested
the evening of June 24 this year,
Tod's Outlet, Albania was admitted into the Goose is located in Baiyun District of New Yuet cafe, using ID to the Internet. At that time, hit the World Cup time, an interest in Arab-Israeli football talent, focus and watch game. Around 11:20 that night, a uniformed police and three security suddenly at his side. A only recall, the name of the police questioned him, he tell us the truth, immediately pressed by three security win, his hands bound by plastic rope, and then was taken to the police station Tongde investigation.
night, A was recorded statement, the police said had not done a bad thing, but not, as the police referred to burglary. That night, Palit A police station was only kept in a room. Now he also clearly remember the night the rain was particularly large, filled with confused and angry.
the following day, Baiyun Taihe police station came to a police and security will only bring Tai O Police Station continuing.
detention
police station in Tai Wo, A was repeatedly asked by the police, For such police questioning, one by one, O only are refuted. He said he had never been to Wo, and no where to commit crimes, nor such as the police called on January 27 this year, burglary. A just said that the time the robbery was Jan. 27, he has returned to my hometown in Henan, the village he is able to prove that hundreds of people.
Although it has been for their own defense Ah, but still the police as a suspect. Baiyun District, Guangzhou City Branch of the Public Security Bureau detention notice show at 10:00 on June 25, 2010, A suspicion of robbery was criminal detention, detention in the Baiyun District Detention Center.
A detention center was only locked up after two days into the belly grain rice is not until the third day hungry, he began to eat. A just said that the detention center have not fared well, food was poor, and sometimes a meal the food is just a salted egg,
Tods shoes Off a large survey of national leisure,Tod's men's shoes Off a larg, a sausage. In which to eat well, often have to work a day in addition to practicing meditation, back prison regulations, but also to engage in health, handyman, the days are tough.
35 天 released
A even after the detention was only affected his parents and son. A high A-tsai's brother, said police wanted the Internet before Afghanistan, Albania was only after the police had not timely revocation of detention warrant the Internet, so that two days after his brother was detained the night,
Tod's men's shoes, dozens of Henan, the local police turned over the wall force into his home searched, questioned the whereabouts of his parents before Ah, sleeping sister in law and nephew were awakened by the police action.
A strong, said a few days later, the hearts of worried wife with two children came to Afghanistan to find it in Guangzhou. Initially, A has been concealing strong wife, said that only people Ah good, nor do bad things out after a few days will be able to go home. A strong can not expect, A was arrested after police found several times, although They argue, but Afghanistan still has only been held in detention centers. Finally, A strong not Yuan Huang, had the wife tells the truth.
A strong that the wife was informed that Afghanistan was only detained, distracted, almost every day in tears, or even several days without food. The tension in his family look forward to the final Baiyun District People's Procuratorate to the fact that clear and the evidence was insufficient to make the decision not to arrest A. July 29 this year, was Jingfangxingju A 35-day personal freedom was restored.
received compensation
A was acquitted, subsequent to the Guangzhou Baiyun Branch of Municipal Public Security Bureau detention claims made mistakes. Baiyun Public Security Bureau shows criminal compensation decision, A claimant for compensation only for the state, is determined as follows: A claimant was paid June 25, 2010 to July 29, 2010 was detained 35 days a total of 4390.05 yuan in compensation. > Compensation payment received after the A before Youxiang Guangzhou Public Security Bureau for criminal compensation for reconsideration. He put forward the spirit of compensation, compensation for restriction of personal freedom honorary compensation and a total of 15 million, and demanded an apology, Baiyun District Public Security Bureau (online public apology) and restore the reputation of the home, eliminating the effects.
Guangzhou Municipal Public Security Bureau Criminal reconsideration decision, said, lack of relevant factual and legal basis, the Council decided as follows: maintain the obligations of institutions, Baiyun District, Guangzhou Public Security Bureau Branch of the compensation decisions, within the scope of its actions for eliminating the effects of the claimant to restore the reputation of an apology.
suit
A before that, his detention, mental injury, also suffered loss of reputation, he proposed meet the requirements for compensation, there is nothing wrong. Moreover, he was detained in the period, his wife took his son to Guangzhou should cost. Guangzhou Municipal Public Security Bureau for criminal compensation is still not satisfied with the reconsideration decision.
11 30, A formally to the Intermediate People's Court of Guangzhou City Baiyun Public Security Bureau. Yesterday afternoon, an official of Guangzhou City Intermediate People's Court hearing the case. For just before the Arab claims made by, white clouds, said the respondent court related personnel branch, according to the After the police personnel responsible Baiyun has apologized to the plaintiff calls, but its arrogance, did not accept the apology. XingJu police the day the plaintiff to remove the plaintiff's online wanted.
A then said he Detention period, the spirit of the affected, damaged reputation, personal freedom is restricted, and the complaint to the police several times to no avail, still XingJu 35 days,
The rise of the post pet matchmaking match up to a thousand dollars because of the different species, which is totally the police investigators errors caused by the compensation granted. The apology did not call the police before the sincerity. A just said that he XingJu, the villagers have been aware of this, the responsible police clouds are proposed to go to his home must face their parents, sister and two nephews and his home village leaders to apologize. Yesterday, the Court did not make a court verdict on the matter.
last night, A reporter was told the Southern, the Court will sentence within three working days, he looked forward to the Court's judgments.
■ lawyers say
the Responsibility to increase the intensity of law enforcement officers at fault
asked Beijing lawyer Zhou Ze-day law firm that was the case completely, O should occur. According to relevant requirements, for the prosecution of the person, without prior ruling, access to non-custodial treatment is a fundamental right, in criminal proceedings, the bail and under house is a principle, to take custody of suspects, coercive measures to arrest is the exception, however, the reality of criminal justice practice exactly the opposite. Detention or arrest, the evidence needs to have basic, but now many are accustomed to public security organs will start to find evidence of criminal suspects. Police handling process, if able to maintain awareness of the presumption of innocence, listen to suspect defense, used the defendant guilty of the evidence, not bent forward to the whole people into criminals, perhaps not such a wrong arrest the problem.
caught on the wrong way arrested the wrong circumstances, in addition to state compensation to victims, payment of state compensation to the victim, eliminating the effects of apology, pay in emotional, as well as necessary to exist the fault of law enforcement increase law enforcement officers responsible for efforts to recover.
Tod's Outlet Lost ID card was the wrong,Tod's Outl
Linear Mode
