The amount of money being spent now on patent armaments is staggering. Google will spend $12.5 billion to acquire Motorola. Earlier this summer,
Apple Pro MC026LL/A, a consortium including Apple,
Sony HDR-CX12, Microsoft,
Canon EOS 1D Mark IV, and Research In Motion,
ASUS G53JW-3DE, bought 6,
HP EliteBook 8740w XT908UT,000 Nortel patents for $4.5 billion.
That is,
Canon EOS 7D, if it weren't for Intellectual Ventures,
Sony HDR-AX2000, which has a patent portfolio but unlike the superpowers doesn't actually make products. Since I don't think you can sue a company for holding a patent it's not using, that makes IV a major wildcard.
What happens to the smaller companies? Every start-up and small company with a germ of an innovation now knows that a large company has the potential to nuke it from orbit,
Canon Vixia HV30, as it were. Even more than before. Will they? Not when they're small, most likely. It's rarely worth the effort. And deploying a patent attack against a small player tips a hand that might be better concealed for later play against a more serious competitor.
Wouldn't you prefer a good game of chess?
Google's maneuver may yet have a stifling effect,
HP EliteBook 8540p XT923UT, though. It could lead to a growth in patent indemnification. One of the things Google may do with its huger patent portfolio is indemnify
Android developers against patent lawsuits,
Sony HDR-SR7, just as Microsoft does for Windows developers when it comes to Linux issues. Again, Intellectual Ventures may also play in this game. This company seems to like getting hooks into growing businesses early, mob style, and the potential threat to IV from Google and other superpower portfolios may lead it to step up its protection business with smaller companies not already under the wing of a superpower.
But even if the playing field ends up leveled among the major players, the downsides of this build-up are numerous and expensive: a lot of money and effort goes to lawyers,
Sony HVR-HD1000E, money that otherwise could have gone to even more development,
Apple MacBook Pro MB471LL/A, the acquisition of start-up companies,
ASUS NX90JQ-B1, or perhaps even stock dividends.
The accumulation of patent portfolios into a smaller number of bigger players, which themselves are locked in a deadly standoff, has the real potential to slow down the pace of innovation. Which is precisely the opposite reason the patent system was created.
While there are many things Google gets with a Motorola Mobility acquisition,
Panasonic AG HPX170, like its own handset hardware manufacturer and a working set-top box market,
Sony HVR-HD1000U, what Google is really acquiring is a patent portfolio. Google CEO Larry Page,
Panasonic AG-HMC80, in his blog post announcing the proposed buy,
HP EliteBook 2740p XT936UT, didn't say that Google needs the inventions covered by the Motorola patents. Rather,
JVC GS-TD1BUS, he said clearly that Google just needs the patents themselves.
In other words, smaller companies are going to end up the pawns of the big patent portfolio holders even more than they are already. The big downside to this is that it can lock companies into platform decisions and directions at early stages,
SONY VAIO VPCF13CGX/B, when they should be taking bigger market risks.
Shall we play a game? How about global thermonuclear war? Let's build an arsenal that will obliterate the enemy if we use it. Bonus: Just by its existence, it keeps emerging powers hidden in their caves.
For the emerging patent superpowers--Apple,
Alienware M14x, Microsoft, Google--the likely end result of this nuclear build-up could be a legal stalemate that may in fact free up the giants to maneuver on the product side. While every launch may carry with it a back-room patent agreement (I'll agree to not sue you on patent X today if you agree to not sue me on Patent Y when I launch my new thing tomorrow), the balance of power could in,
Canon XH A1, in a limited way, work in favor of innovation at the large companies.
And just to make it interesting,
HP EliteBook 8740w XT909UT, how about we give the launch codes to lawyers?
相关的主题文章：
hp IDS 2540P-In other violence
ThinkPad T420s- while the robot trounces iOS and Symbian in Q2.
Canon XH A1-
JVC GZ-HD6-Lately
www.gosale777.com- Logitech Harmony 300
Apple MacBook Pro MB471LL/A- well
Panasonic AG-HMC70-
Screenshot by Jason Parker/CNET
Google+ It's more of a suburban parents thing Technically Incorrect - CNET News
HP EliteBook 2740p XT935UT- Abdul Basir Salangi
Toshiba Tecra R840-S8440- take images
Sony HXR-MC2000U-Worse
Canon Wide Angle EF 35mm f/1.4L USM Autofocus Lens- AFP and Reuters.
Sony F136FX/B-"Ah so that's the current running price for an arm
Sony HDR-FX7-Google's effort joins others to invalidate patents from Lodsys
ASUS NX90JQ-B1-Related Articles
$20 Logitech Harmony 200 universal remote hits Radio Shack Crave - CNET
Alienware M14x- Microsoft
Hybrid Mode
